Which snow retainer is better: a comparative review of the 7 best designs

When snow covers the landscape in the winter, a roof’s integrity becomes crucial to its longevity and safety. Snow retention systems, which are important but frequently disregarded, are essential in preventing unexpected snow slides that could endanger people below or cause property damage. Selecting the appropriate snow retainer requires knowledge of different designs and features. We examine seven of the top snow retainer designs in this comparison review to assist you in making an informed choice that will safeguard both your roof and people nearby.

Rooftop snow retention systems are used to control the buildup and melting of snow and ice. In the absence of these systems, large snowfalls may suddenly slide off roofs, endangering nearby cars, buildings, and pedestrians. In addition to preventing these slides, the best snow retainers equally distribute the weight of the snow across the roof, lessening the strain on the structure and increasing its longevity.

The pad-style snow guard is one common snow retention design. Usually arranged in rows along the roof, these guards use a flat or slightly concave surface to hold snow in place. A different kind that works well is called a fence-style snow retainer; it looks like a little fence or rail that is put in parallel to the edge of the roof. This pattern collects snow and keeps it from falling all at once by allowing it to melt or evaporate gradually.

There are hybrid designs that combine the practicality of several styles with a low-key appearance for those who are concerned about aesthetics. These are functional and aesthetically pleasing, blending in seamlessly with different types of roofing materials.

Considerations including roof pitch, climate, type of roof, and local building codes are important when choosing a snow retention system. The seven designs that have been reviewed here each have special benefits, whether it be in terms of durability, ease of installation, or efficacy in preventing snow slides. Homeowners and builders can select the ideal snow retainer that best meets their requirements and guarantees a safer environment during snowy seasons by being aware of these options.

Snow Retainer Design Key Features
1. Clamp-On Snow Guard Attaches directly to the roof seams, easy installation, suitable for various roof types
2. Pad-Style Snow Guard Uses individual pads to hold snow, customizable spacing, aesthetic appeal
3. Fence-Style Snow Guard Creates a barrier to hold snow, durable materials, good for high snow load areas
4. Pipe-Style Snow Guard Uses vertical pipes to prevent snow sliding, versatile design, effective in moderate snowfall
5. Rail-Style Snow Guard Horizontal rails for snow retention, robust construction, suitable for commercial buildings
6. Wire-Rope Snow Guard Uses wire ropes to hold snow, flexible installation, good for curved roofs
7. Hybrid Snow Guard Combines features of multiple designs, optimized for specific roof configurations, versatile

Know-how, or necessary security?

For Russian consumers, snow retention systems are a relatively new idea. Snow retainers have been an essential component of European roof configurations for a considerable amount of time. However, the local market is still learning how to properly showcase this product, and many locals believe that this is just another way for big manufacturers to make money.

But let’s use reason here. At -8°C, a meter layer of loose snow is equivalent to 10 cm of water or 60 kg per square meter, and the same volume of wet snow is equivalent to 200 kg of pressure per square meter! Imagine now that all of this "good" falls on a person’s head or a pricey car. As a result, in developed nations, it is even necessary to shield car parking spaces and passing platforms from any potential snowdrops dropped by homeowners.

Many more owners of the brand-new home with the gorgeous roof reject the snow detention system, which is the reason why the roof will eventually look ugly.

Of course, a standard log or set of planks won’t look natural on anything, but contemporary snow retention systems come in a lot of stylish options, including gratings, brackets, and planks that have curly decorative elements and look amazing:

Granted, snow holders are not exempt from this rule.

However, you will agree that this item, "There is almost no snow in your region," has nothing to do with Russia?

What about official recommendations?

There are eight distinct snow load zones in Russia, as stated in the most recent SNiP "Struggles and Influences" report. Numerous roof parameters, including those related to the security systems and rafter system design, are computed using this data.

The use of snow retainers is not governed by any registered regulations in SNiPs, and the documents pertaining to these elements only offer recommendations.

Consequently, it is customary to rely solely on common sense and the necessity to ensure security when installing snow retainers in latitudes in Russia. The blood inclination angle, the slope’s length, the wind and snow load, the location relative to other points on Earth, the kind of roofing material, and the proximity of nearby structures, walkways, and parking lots are some of the factors that already determine this. Of course, you, the client or home’s owner, still have the last say in matters of policy.

And few people are aware that numerous lives have already been saved by tiny roofing components. Numerous instances exist where home owners have fixed their roofs only to break them off while moving around the slopes in the breeze. In these situations, they were able to grab the snow holders and everything turned out okay. An important disagreement!

In order to identify the most efficient snow retainer design, we compare seven different designs in this article from "All about the Roof." In order to avoid damage and safety risks caused by snow buildup on roofs, snow retainers are essential. We hope to give builders and homeowners clear guidance on selecting the best snow retainer for their unique requirements by looking at elements like longevity, simplicity of installation, and efficacy in different climates. This review will assist you in making an informed decision, regardless of your concerns regarding maintaining the integrity of your roof or guaranteeing safety around your property during the winter.

Types of modern snow retainers and their features

Frequently, ready-made snow retainers are available as an add-on or directly with the full set of roofs. However, this is merely a marketing ploy; it is not a given that these systems will perform admirably and catch your attention.

Snow retainers are, after all, sometimes referred to as extra ornamental roof elements for a reason—where even the craziest designer fantasy can come true! It is therefore preferable to select them yourself, carefully considering the advantages and disadvantages of each species, as well as its dependability and aesthetic value.

Now, let’s take a closer look at the current category of snow retainers available on the market today. Snow barriers are the first kind, and their purpose is to totally obstruct the snow mass. These work better in areas where there is very little to no snow accumulation and little localized melting is required. In order to give the snow enough time to melt and not endanger anyone, the second type of snow retainers splits the snow layer into multiple pieces and lowers them into the drain more slowly.

Logs on hooks: all ingenious – just

The alpine mountains are where we inherited the custom of setting up a log for snow retention. These locations have been using this method of snow retention for many centuries, particularly on tiled roofs. It wasn’t until recently that contemporary engineers adopted this custom and created a design that was precisely the opposite, using creative hooks and metal devices to keep snow off the roof.

The sole disadvantage of this eco-friendly method of retaining snow is that, if you use a regular log on hooks, there’s always a chance that the ice will form beneath the stopper when the snow melts, ripping the log from its fastening. For this reason, contemporary businesses have created a unique installation to make the entire design safer.

Corner snowfields: cheap, but not reliable

Give corner or plate snow holders more thought. These are typically protective coating-coated bent sheets that create a tiny threshold on the roof. Yet, we observe that this kind of snow barrier is the weakest and most straightforward design. Ultimately, these snow retainers are typically made from the same steel sheet that is used to produce metal tiles, given that it is profiled and only stronger against bending because of its ornamental shape.

The sheet even bends with his hands and is only 0.45 millimeters thin. Obviously, the multi-ton snow load is too much for these types of snow retainers. Therefore, an additional internal stiffener element that is mounted inside the bar is frequently used in this corner to give such a design a certain strength.

The principle of action states that snow from the roof is generally not passed down onto corner snowfields. However, the height of the roof currently limits their efficacy, and they are not placed on roofs where snow masses cannot accumulate and at least somewhat delay:

As a result, in this instance, the main corner of the corner is occasionally given the "hillocks," which are little stoppers installed for steep roof slopes. Their small height and ability to retain only the lowest portion of the snow layer prevents the entire avalanche from forming on thin cornering stoppers.

We observe a favorable instance. These snow detectors’ triangular shape offers excellent transverse and longitudinal load stiffness. Similarly, there aren’t many choices for employing snow holders for ceramic or cement-sandy piece tiles; among them, these snowmobiles are among the most dependable.

In order to distribute the snow load evenly across the entire area of the roof, metal corners are also frequently installed in a checkerboard pattern across multiple rows, rather than just one at the cornice. Such snow retainers should be attached in steps that are twice as wide as the tiles.

Lattice snow holders: double benefits

Snow retainers, also known as decorative lattice, are utilized. They are always installed using brackets, in a line parallel to the roof’s edge:

The following benefits set lattice snow holders apart:

  • Universal, installed on a roof with absolutely any coating.
  • Retain the integrity of the roofing and drains.
  • Ensure a high level of snow safety and protection of open parts of the roofing.
  • Not only contribute to the slow similarity of the snow masses, but also divide them into small parts, thereby reducing the so -called kinetic energy. Snow in such layouts quickly melts and goes with a monolithic layer. And melt water calmly flow into the drain.

These details about their design are further:

These are usually installed on natural tile roofs, and their main purpose is to shield individual split tiles from small pieces that may fall through. Eventually, a substantial amount of snow cap will be unable to support this design. If it malfunctions, it can be fixed with a cornice bar and drains jointly, which is the primary drawback.

The size, design, and even manufacturing processes of the individual lattice snow holders vary from one another. Standard versions with longitudinal stripes soldered to both corners are the most widely used. However, snow retainers are thought to be more fashionable; the ornament in these pieces is laser-cut directly onto a steel plate, bending at the edges. They appear so incredible!

We also record such an instance. Large areas of contact with snow characterize these lattices, and their support brackets are under significant load. As a result, without breaking any rules, these snow retainers must only be attached to the roof’s rafter system and not to this coating. Furthermore, boards need to be used to reinforce these fastenings. For this reason, it is best to call in a specialist to install the lattice snow holders rather than doing it yourself. This is also considered a negative.

Network Snow holders: Snow cutting with cubes

The term "lattice" also applies to network snow holders, albeit with slightly different arrangements. They are constructed with a sturdy metal frame shaped like a grid. Compared to private roofs, multi-story buildings’ roofs or roofs with natural tile are where they are most frequently installed.

These snow holders are 12 to 25 centimeters long and up to 15 centimeters high. These snow retainers come in one type, or combine two types with the aid of unique grooves. Maintaining wet snow, which is challenging to remove at such a height and which quickly turns into an ice mass, is the primary function of such a roofing element. Cheap and enraged!

Tough snow retainers, or "teeth"

Alternatively known as "piece" snow retainers, dentate snow retainers work more like snow cutters. These components resemble curved bars with hooks or teeth at the ends. They are put on roofs, whose coatings are applied after considerable snowfall. We are discussing flexible tiles made of comparable materials.

Sometimes, for example, on a керамической черепице, зубчатые снегозадержатели устанавливаят в комплекте с решетчатыми.

They appear as follows:

Easy to use, dependable, and very stylish.

Tubular snow holders: for the most difficult cases

Because of their throughput, tubular snow holders, like lattice, prevent excessive snow accumulation on the roof. They let him crawl gradually, which is not at all harmful on its own.

In total, two varieties are made: one with an 11 mm diameter hollow tube and the other with a 10 to 15 mm diameter steel tube. exceptional in areas where other snow retainers are hopeless.

Here is a brief but helpful video regarding these snow holders:

Polycarbonate snow holders – market novelty!

Since then, polycarbonate has found use throughout the construction industry thanks to a 1955 patent granted by renowned physicist Fox Chemist. Like a snowball, its production spread quickly throughout the world.

Thus, the well-known Finnish company just introduced polycarbonate snow retainers to the market, which are substantially less expensive than traditional metal. However, the quality of products made from this transparent, light material is similar to that of millennium: they have the same scratch, frost, and impact resistance.

It’s enjoyable to work with polycarbonate snow retainers:

These snow holders are extremely valuable because they are the only ones that can be fastened to a roof without creating holes or causing harm to the roofing material:

While combined mounting is often a perfectly acceptable option:

Furthermore, in certain cases, these snow holders represent the sole viable technical solution. One of the main challenges is that contemporary polycarbonate roofs are constructed with a wide crate step and are relatively light in weight. This is understandable given that polycarbonate is a material that is both incredibly strong and light. Fixing it directly to it is an unrealistic task because such roofing elements can only be mounted into the crate, which is nearly nonexistent and was designed to accommodate standard polycarbonate sheet sizes.

You will therefore have to fiddle if you need to install snow holders on the sturdy polycarbonate roof of the workshop or gazebo. And for a common polycarbonate roof, nothing works better than snow retainers made of the same material that can be glued on right away.

It is not worthwhile to proceed in a different manner because, in standard self-cutting, the thread assumes that the polycarbonate is precisely drilled with a different tool, and then inserts a self-tapping screw into it. This connection will not be dependable and it will not be impractical. Naturally, it is far simpler to "find" glue-able transparent snow retainers and to just forget about the issue altogether.

When selecting the ideal snow retainer for your roof, you should take into account a number of important factors, including aesthetic appeal, ease of installation, durability, and effectiveness. Depending on your particular requirements, each of the reviewed designs—such as clamp-on, pad-style, and bar systems—offers a different set of benefits.

Clamp-on designs offer a straightforward solution for individuals who prioritize cost-effectiveness and simplicity. They are perfect for residential roofs where practicality is important because they are simple to install and maintain. These retainers securely hold onto the snow, averting unexpected slides that might harm nearby property or put people in danger.

Conversely, pad-style retainers more evenly distribute the snow load across the surface of the roof. For roofs with different pitches or materials that need to be handled carefully, this design is advantageous. Because they are frequently constructed from sturdy materials like rubber or aluminum, they last a long time and require little upkeep.

Bar systems provide strong protection for high-performance applications or roofs that frequently experience heavy snowfall. These systems lower the risk of unexpected avalanches by using strategically positioned metal bars to hold snow in place while enabling controlled release. They are frequently chosen for commercial buildings or structures that must adhere to strict architectural specifications.

The ideal snow retainer for your roof ultimately comes down to personal taste, climate, and budget. Knowing the advantages and disadvantages of each design will help you choose wisely to protect your property, your roof, and people nearby from the dangers of snow accumulation.

Video on the topic

Snow holders on the roof, choice of choice

Snow holders Leroy Merlen: is it worth buying them? I conducted a comparative test!

Snow holder good or evil? whether the snow will withstand the roof #massly Samostroy #Kryshadom

Why are snow retainers needed, how to choose and install them correctly.

Is it worth buying Newline Snow Exgrolls? We carry out a comparative test with RoofsyStems Prestige

What do you think, which element is the most important for a reliable and durable roof?
Share to friends
Alexander Sorokin

The owner of the roofing company, an expert in the roofing markets. I'll tell you about the novelties of the roofing industry and help you choose the best option for your home.

Rate author
Add a comment