Which is better – metal tile or flexible tile? Comparative review

Selecting between flexible and metal tile for your roof is an important choice that can affect your home’s durability and appearance. Weighing the advantages and disadvantages is crucial before selecting any option because each have particular advantages and things to take into account.

Metal tiles are known for being strong and durable. These tiles, which are usually composed of steel or aluminum, provide exceptional resistance to inclement weather, including rain, snow, and hail. Additionally, they resist fire, which gives your house an extra degree of security. Metal tiles are available in an array of hues and designs, enabling homeowners to create a contemporary or classic aesthetic that perfectly suits their home.

Conversely, flexible tiles offer convenience of installation and versatility. They are typically composed of materials like plastic or synthetic rubber. Because these tiles are lightweight, handling and transporting them during installation is made simpler. Flexible tiles ensure a snug fit that improves weather resistance by easily adjusting to the uneven shapes and contours of roofs. In comparison to metal tiles, they also have a tendency to be quieter during rainfall, which may be important to homeowners who are sensitive to noise.

Each kind of tile has advantages over the other in terms of upkeep. Although they typically require little upkeep, metal tiles should be periodically inspected for any indications of corrosion or damage. They usually don’t need to be painted and are simple to clean. In regions that are vulnerable to strong winds or extreme temperatures, flexible tiles may need to be inspected more frequently to make sure they stay securely attached to the roof and intact.

Because of their sturdy construction and installation needs, metal tiles can be more expensive up front. However, because of their longer lifespan and advantages in energy efficiency, they can result in long-term savings. Initially, flexible tiles are usually less expensive than metal tiles, but they may need to be replaced sooner due to their shorter lifespan.

The decision between flexible and metal tile ultimately comes down to your personal requirements and tastes. If you value longevity, resistance to fire, and a variety of style options, metal tiles might be a better option. Flexible tiles may be the best choice for people who want a low initial cost, ease of installation, and versatility. Think about speaking with a roofing expert to determine the precise needs for your roof and help you make the best choice for your house.

Taste and functionality issues

What is the appearance of both kinds of tiles on a house’s roof?

The qualities of the two types of roofs will be compared in this article. It is also not surprising that producers like contrasting their flexible tiles with metal, as if they were of completely different quality:

Structure: what you need to know about?

Let’s begin by examining the two coatings’ structures. In fact, the only reason why so many people prefer metal tiles these days is that they think of the soft ones as being similar to roofing materials, even though, technically speaking, metal is far more complex, reliable, and has a much more complex structure.

Describe a flexible tile, please. This is a set of figure cuts and standard-sized sheet material. This kind of product is multilayered, with bitumen-saturated material on top of glass chloride (non-woven fiberglass).

Important characteristics that set apart the races of various manufacturers include design, color scheme, form, strength of base, astringent bitumen quality, soil thickness, and sprinkle method. In this case, the bitumen itself is very important. His great-grandfather is the one who is concerned about the behavior of the flexible tiles on the roof.

These sheets’ primary benefit is their resistance to longitudinal stretching. Additionally, bituminous tiles with double reinforcement exhibit particularly high strength characteristics. Moreover, the races are treated with a unique composition even in factory settings to guard against lichens and mold while in use. Even now, titan plates made of copper, zinc, and aluminum are used in the production of bitumen tiles.

However, the metal tile’s structure is essentially different:

The metal tile’s foundation is a steel sheet with an extra layer of protection applied on top and a layer of aluminum or zinc underneath. Such a layer pie, and each of these materials’ focus will have an instant impact on the material’s durability.

The topmost layer holds significant importance; observe how the sheet’s properties alter instantly between versions:

In summary, the structure of metal and flexible tiles is intricate, and the quality of these materials is contingent upon the specific material used, the number of layers applied, and the type of manufacturing technology employed. T.e. Metal and flexible tiles are not fundamentally simple analogs.

Color and design: which will delight the eye more?

The choice of roofing material is influenced by two key factors, the first of which is aesthetics. Ultimately, it makes no sense to consider every last detail when designing a new home, including the color of the facade, the design of the window frames, and how the roof will ruin the whole look.

And this is where the bonds and the metallo-tank differ greatly! The RAL catalog offers a good selection of colors for the metal tile, but naturally, they are all monochrome. Furthermore, because there aren’t any such pure hues in nature, the metal tile always seems out of place against the surrounding landscape despite its stylish appearance. However, a multicolored metal tile is not made available:

Flexible tiles, which are now available with two primary types of upper coating—basalt and shale crumbs—are an entirely different matter. Such misting serves as a decorative element as well as shielding sheets from UV rays and other harmful elements.

Because of how lovely and varied the colors are, it is easy to create the desired modern architectural style. Additionally, top manufacturers actively compete with one another every year by producing something new.

Naturally, a roofing like this appears harmonious in both urban latitudes and when set against a backdrop of the outdoors:

Possibilities of implementing projects: from simple – to complex

Owing to the substantial amount of waste, the integrity of the metal tile sheets and their inability to bend to a high standard make them ideal for straightforward projects like roofs with two straight slopes and no excess. Elevated aerobatics for metallic tiles – holly and tent roofs, followed by the need for tinning in the sealing and ridge arrangement.

The truth is that all of the metal tile’s textures require even slopes, and any bend or intricate feature causes a lot of issues. Even on regular roofs, the percentage of metal tiles used does not fall below 15%; however, at odd architectural objects, the percentage can occasionally surpass 50%.

However, aside from a flat surface, there are no barriers at all with flexible tiles. This is why it can be used to create simple, complex configurations and stunning roofs, including bulbous and domed ones. And all because flexible tiles are made of one piece, meaning that a single problematic area never compromises the coating’s integrity.

Metal tiles are not suitable for creating attractive corner elements on a complex roof. Furthermore, it is still very challenging to guarantee waterproofing of such elements, even with the unique skill and ingenuity of the roofer. But things are entirely different when you use a flexible tile!

This is a really fascinating video about the subject:

Practicality: which tile will show itself better?

Consider the practicality of both roof types if the aesthetics is satisfied.

Noise insulation: will there be a roar?

We have now reached the primary distinction, which is the subject of much discussion: noise insulation. Thus, it is advised to forgo metal tiles if you wish to turn your home’s attic into an attic. After all, the noise caused by rain is only somewhat attenuated by high-quality insulation. However, flexible tiles are a completely silent substance.

However, if you select a heater with excellent soundproofing qualities and don’t forget to replace the self-tapping screws (metal sheets often rust from the wind), i.e., handle the situation skillfully, then such an attic will end up being fairly comfortable. For this reason, knowledgeable roofers suggest against buying metal tile screws from the market, where "everything for everything" is sold. It is preferable to order a set of these from a specialized retailer, using a rubber-based gasket.

You won’t mind if it is noisy under the roof during a downpour if the attic is cold and insulation isn’t an issue because the sound won’t enter the living space.

Snow retention: avalanche -shaped snow gathering

Snow retention is the next moment. It is crucial that snow on residential buildings, which is common in Russia, does not descend in an avalanche-like manner. After all, a "hat" like that can harm the car, break the pricey shrubs growing nearby, clog the drains, and even beat the dog that is walking below.

Consequently, snow retainers will need to be installed on the metal tile. However, flexible tiles do not require them because there is little chance of this kind of snow accumulation, primarily because of a rough surface from stone fragments. The only thing that will periodically scratch and pull the bitumen tile away from it is snow, especially when it’s wet and contains ice fragments. Snow is essential for protecting bitumen against sunlight.

Environmental issues: We dispel myths

Concerns regarding bitumen tiles’ quality frequently center on the material’s lack of environmental friendliness. Furthermore, the sun’s heat from the bitumen will separate harmful substances into the air, poisoning nearby wildlife and people. However, this is actually limited to the use of false, subpar tiles.

Indeed, only premium natural bitumen—also known as "earthen resin"—is used by contemporary manufacturers to create roofing. He published something that was completely waterproof thanks to housing.

This type of bitumen is not the same as the bitumen used to adhere roofing materials to slopes; rather, it is a naturally occurring substance that is saturated with oxygen, setting it apart from chemicals.

Budgetary: We take into account the pitfalls

And now for the most delicate of all: the cost. Buyers want to preserve the house’s aesthetic appeal while still making high-quality purchases, even if they have a tight budget. Of course, flexible tiles cost more than metal, but not by enough to change the original plan.

The second thing to note. The costs of metal tiles are fairly clear-cut and reasonable: super-thin and artisanal tiles, which are directly sold on the market, will be less expensive, and high-quality tiles have their own price. However, things get a little trickier when it comes to flexible tiles. In fact, in the home market, it’s not uncommon to find tiles that are twice as expensive as their equivalents while still being inferior.

For instance, there once was a reasonably robust and long-lasting American bitumen tile available for purchase that, while not as good as European in many aspects, was less expensive.

Finally, in the context of the current import substitution policy, Russian manufacturing facilities take quality seriously and employ cutting-edge technologies, whereas in many other countries, production plans have remained largely unchanged for the previous 20 to 30 years. It turns out that some domestic tiles nowadays are substantially more expensive than their foreign counterparts, despite having comparable quality.

Furthermore, it is acceptable that there is no monopoly in the flexible tile market because producers compete with one another by releasing new collections and raising the standard of the racing. Regarding metal tiles, the primary competitors are Grand Line and Metal Profile; the remaining competitors are, with rare exceptions, solely artisans’ products.

And lastly, consider the potential overrun of the material if we discuss the price. Even though a metal tile costs less overall than a flexible tile by at least 40%, trimming makes up for it all.

Durability and ease of care

The metal tile has an overall warranty of 10 to 20 years, but in actual use, it might last up to 50 years if there are no scratches, no corrosion risks, and all fasteners are made flawlessly.

It is true that since the metal tile is relatively new to the Russian market, no one has checked for a long time. However, the guarantee for a flexible tile is only offered for ten to fifty years, even though in practice it lasts for fifteen to seventy years. And once more, neither of these was verified.

Despite the fact that these brief investigations and tests of the two types of coatings will be curious to observe:

Also in the future, the care for the bitumen roof will cost much cheaper, t.To. it is considered the most repair. Let"s compare: if a leak appears in some place, it is enough to create a couple of hounds with the help of one nail and replace them with new ones, and at the same time, a metallic tile will have to be squeezed out to the base of several tubes of expensive sealant, or even remove and even remove and even remove it. Replace entire sheets. In addition, one problem gont does not affect the entire slope, and only one scratch in a metal tile causes corrosion throughout the slope.

Metal Tile Flexible Tile
Pros: Durable, resistant to weather and fire, long lifespan. Pros: Lightweight, easy to install, suitable for complex roof shapes.
Cons: Higher initial cost, noise during rain or hail. Cons: Less durable than metal, may require more frequent replacement.

There are a few important considerations that should influence your decision when choosing between flexible and metal tiles for your roof. Metal tiles are strong and long-lasting; with little upkeep, they can last for at least 50 years. They are an excellent long-term investment in the security of your home because they are resistant to rot, fire, and insects.

Conversely, flexible tiles are very versatile and simple to install; they are usually made of plastic or synthetic rubber. Because they weigh less than metal tiles, they may require less installation money and less stress on the structure. Additionally insulating well and more resilient to impact damage, flexible tiles can be advantageous in regions that frequently experience severe weather.

Regarding aesthetics, each choice provides a variety of colors and styles to accommodate varying architectural tastes. Metal roofing tiles frequently resemble slate or clay roof materials, offering a traditional look with contemporary durability. However, flexible tiles allow for greater creative freedom in roof design because they can be molded into a variety of shapes and textures.

Flexible tiles typically have lower initial costs because they require less money for materials and installation. But over the course of your roof’s lifetime, the durability and low maintenance needs of metal tiles can offset this initial cost, making them an economical option.

The choice between metal and flexible tiles ultimately comes down to your personal preferences, financial constraints, and needs. Metal tiles might be a better choice if longevity, toughness, and a classic appearance are important to you. Flexible tiles might be the best option for people looking for low costs, simple installation, and flexible design. To ensure that your decision ensures your home’s functionality and style, think about speaking with a roofing professional to evaluate your unique situation.

Each material has advantages over the other when it comes to roofing: metal tiles and flexible tiles. Metal tiles are a great option for longevity and safety because of their well-known resilience to fire. Conversely, flexible tiles are unique in that they are lightweight and simple to install, making them suitable for a wide range of architectural designs. In order to assist homeowners in making an informed choice based on their unique needs for durability, aesthetics, and installation convenience, this article examines the advantages of both options.

Video on the topic

We answer the question!metal tile or soft tile.

Eternal roof for home. All the same, yes or not? Metal tile or bitumen flexible tile?

That the metal tile or flexible tile is better? // Dragon tooth // Simple and complex tile laying

Flexible tiles after 12 years: moss on the roof, leakage? Best Home Roof: ICOPAL Soft Tiles

What do you think, which element is the most important for a reliable and durable roof?
Share to friends
Denis Shcherbakov

Professional roofer with 20 years of experience. I know everything about the installation, repair and maintenance of various types of roofs. I will be happy to share my knowledge and experience with you.

Rate author
Add a comment